March definitely hasn't been my month so far (and the lack of blog posts prove that), with work being exceptionally busy and particularly infuriating (all at the same time, preventing any usual compartmentalization I would normally employ), and social media discourse has been driving me nuts, to the point that I'm considering dropping Twitter for good (save, maybe, keeping the podcast one up...but it's not like that gets any engagement).
I don't know what it is about discourse that bothers me so much, but it really upsets me most of the time. And not because I don't like disagreements (which I don't, as I've discussed before), but due to some vague sense of discomfort that results from seeing it.
Post-Oscars has turned into a series of nonsensical arguments and binary decisions between Sinners and One Battle After Another (either you must ONLY LIKE ONE, or OBAA IS RACIST BECAUSE IT DEPICTS RACISM or some kind of nonsense like that, or SINNERS IS JUST FROM DUSK TIL DAWN), people who apparently don't know who Paul Thomas Anderson is...and then there's the Marvel Vs DC (an argument that literally comes down to "whomever makes more money is clearly superior," which is utterly ridiculous) stemming from the release of a new Spider-Man trailer, "Dune is better than Star Wars" , an off-the-cuff joke taken so seriously that even Grant Morrison thinks the reason Lanterns is called that is because Damon Lindelof thinks "Green is dumb."
That's just the last few days on Twitter.
The thing is, if someone doesn't like something, or just doesn't care about something, I honestly don't care at all. Even if it's something I love. But when something is patently untrue, unresearched, or even thoughtlessly discarded, it makes me feel badly inside in ways I can't seem to fully understand. Most people seem to not care very much, if at all, or engage in huge arguments over it (which is where my discomfort with disagreement *does* come in: I never engage in fights over this stuff because I fear it'll get carried away, or it'll get personal, or someone who I care about will get their feelings hurt (or they'll hurt mine), or some sort of negative outcome will occur. Certainly, no argument is going to change anyone's mind.
Maybe that is what bothers me so much. It's not so much the opinion (you can think Dune is somehow more culturally and artistically relevant than Star Wars, I don't care), but the misplaced confidence in those opinions.
Before the internet, I don't remember this level of sheer confidence in something entirely made up, something nonsensical, something that cannot be proven or disproven. Opinion confidently stated as unassailable fact. And I'm not entirely sure where this came from, if it existed beforehand and, again, why the hell it upsets me so much. Personally, I think it's the result of "everyone has the right to their opinion" being taken too seriously. It's how we got shit like Trump. Hell, Trump even helped to normalize it: we all remember "Alternative Facts" being pushed, right? Combined with a generous helping of main character syndrome and weaponized therapy speak, set in an arena of anonymity, and the stupidest battle lines are drawn.
And some of it isn't even honest! We have rage baiting posts seeking to stir up outrage for attention (because attention is monetized, not based on merit, so a tantrum gets rewarded), while at the same time "heartwarming" stories (I have seen the same "My niece stuck up for me at thanksgiving when my uncle said something transphobic" story repeated verbatim four times, to the point that I find myself doubting it ever happened...but maybe it did, at some point, because it's not like people don't just steal posts for their own engagement metrics) and cute pet reels are also freely spread dishonestly.
I think maybe that's it. Dishonesty. I make two different podcasts that are pretty much literally just me sharing my opinions. But they are honest ones. I thought about them. I researched when I didn't know or understand something (but not through those insipid "Joe Dirt explained" videos, and certainly not from a video of a man nodding his head in front of a TV screen while a movie plays and oh my goddess I hate the content era and also it is CAST not casted and the next person who uses "Coldest" instead of "coolest" gets a roaring elbow to the neck), and it is explained and extrapolated on. I have never, and will never, say something just to get a response. Hell, neither podcast has a particularly large listener base because we avoid shouting about our existence too loudly or forcefully. If we switched to being controversial hate-mongering grifters, or just rage baited, we'd probably be rich.
I can deal with certain levels of stupid in my life, if that stupidity comes from an honest place. I'd rather be in conversation with someone who simply doesn't know stuff than someone who clearly doesn't know stuff but pretends they do. THAT causes anxiety. Because it's just in bad faith. There's no conversation to be had, just a dumb, uninformed mound that is convinced it's a genius because it thought Bergman was overrated, reading is hard, and "Hollywood is cooked because look at this bad computer game cut scene my AI made." There's no conversation to be had. Just confidently poor opinions, based on whatever random thought they felt they could get away.
And the final element, I think, to tie it more to my own mental health struggles is that I cannot quite reconcile any of it in an orderly way. It's chaotic, messy, a swirling tempest of ideas that swing around mindlessly. It's the twister scene from Wizard of Oz: dog barking, I'm dizzy, houses and cows are flying by, and my mean neighbor is a witch for some reason. None of it is tied down, or grounded, just stuff thrown around without meaning. And this is the generally harmless stuff (in the end, nobody can possibly be hurt over Sinners is the best film ever and One Battle After Another is bad except the person who has that opinion because, guess what, both films are pretty amazing...however, the idea that this years Best Picture Oscar field was better than 1975's is harmful, because you should see those movies if you want to be "good at film discourse," but that would involve challenging your horizons, and why do that when you can just rage bait and, seriously, I hate the modern internet). This isn't the "Making AI art of Sabrina Carpenter naked" or "Create a rumor that *insert female wrestler here* had sex with *insert male wrestling personality here*" stuff.
I cannot make sense of it. It's hard. And so it makes me angry and tired and anxious because I simply cannot wrap my head around even a single element of it. I'm big on managing to find common ground, if only because sometimes I find I don't understand emotional and psychological nuance as much as I should, and have become strangely literal, so I have to re-focus, and contextualize encounters and thoughts to make them fit, which is where a practiced empathy comes into play. I may not be able to fully understand, say, the logic of an idea or behavior, but I can understand the emotional core of it, the "I think I get why you are saying or doing these things, even if I don't know the what or how" of it all. I can understand something stupid being said or done in the moment, especially now when everyone is really amped up about pretty much everything because we're all being digested by late stage capitalism. I get why you might be mad Buffy isn't getting a reboot, even if I don't know why that is causing you to say the things you are.
Anyway, just as I think I started to find a groove, it's time for me to return to the salt mines and wish for a personal medical emergency that will allow me to leave. Still not sleeping well.
As always, thanks for reading. May be a little more intense and annoying than my usual.
But I just don't understand things sometimes.